A Guide to Choosing the Perfect Engagement Ring: New vs Pre-Owned

by Lowri Watkins

An engagement ring is more than just a piece of jewellery—it symbolises love, commitment, and the beginning of a lifelong journey together. At Gold Reserves, we offer a stunning collection of both new and vintage gold jewellery, including engagement rings, to suit every taste and budget. Whether you’re looking for a brand-new sparkler or a timeless antique piece, this guide will help you make an informed decision.

How to Choose an Engagement Ring

Selecting the perfect engagement ring can feel overwhelming, but keeping these key factors in mind will make the process smoother:

  1. Set a Budget – Engagement rings come in a wide range of prices, so it’s important to determine what you’re comfortable spending before you start shopping.

  2. Choose the Right Metal – Yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold are classic choices. Each has a unique aesthetic, so pick the one that best complements your partner’s style.

  3. Pick a Diamond Shape – The diamond’s cut affects its sparkle and overall appearance. More on this below!

  4. Understand the 4 Cs – Cut, Colour, Clarity, and Carat are the key characteristics of a diamond that determine its quality and value.

  5. Consider Your Partner’s Style – Pay attention to their existing jewellery to understand their preferences, whether they love vintage pieces or modern designs.

Understanding Diamond Cuts

The cut of a diamond greatly impacts its brilliance and shape. Here are some of the most popular cuts:

  • Round Brilliant – The most popular diamond cut, known for its exceptional brilliance and timeless appeal.

  • Princess Cut – A square shape with sharp edges that offers a contemporary yet elegant look.

  • Oval Cut – Elongated for a sophisticated appearance, it can make the finger appear longer and more slender.

  • Emerald Cut – Featuring step-cut facets, this rectangular cut exudes vintage charm with a more understated sparkle.

  • Cushion Cut – A soft, square shape with rounded corners, perfect for a romantic and antique feel.

  • Marquise Cut – With its elongated, pointed ends, this cut maximises carat weight and creates a striking effect.

  • Pear Cut – Resembling a teardrop, this cut is both unique and elegant.

  • Asscher Cut – A vintage-inspired square cut with step-cut facets that give it an Art Deco feel.

New vs Pre-Owned Engagement Rings

Choosing between a new or pre-owned engagement ring is a personal decision, each offering its own benefits and considerations.

New Engagement Rings

✅ Pros:

  • Customisable to your exact specifications

  • Often come with warranties and certifications

  • A brand-new piece, free from previous ownership history

❌ Cons:

  • Typically more expensive than pre-owned options

  • May lack the character and unique history of vintage rings

Pre-Owned Engagement Rings

✅ Pros:

  • Unique designs, often with intricate vintage craftsmanship

  • More affordable than new rings

  • Environmentally friendly—buying second-hand reduces the demand for newly mined materials

❌ Cons:

  • Limited availability in specific styles and sizes

  • May show signs of wear (although this can add to its charm!)

Find Your Perfect Engagement Ring at Gold Reserves

Whether you prefer the brilliance of a brand-new diamond or the timeless beauty of a vintage piece, Gold Reserves has an exceptional selection of engagement rings to explore. Our expert team is here to help you find the perfect ring that tells your love story. Visit us today to discover our stunning range of new and pre-owned gold jewellery.

Back to Blog